Skip to content
The Digitalist Team
September 18, 2026

Buy or Build? How AI Changes the Software ROI Equation

A vendor demonstrates an invoice-search assistant built into its portal. A development team shows you a similar feature it produced in an afternoon. Both demos work. Your investment decision depends on a harder question: how much will it cost to give every distributor the right invoice, reliably, for the next three years?

Price the work that survives the demo

Packaged software can put a working feature in users’ hands early. Find out which licence includes it, whether external users need paid seats, and how usage above the allowance is charged. Test it with a cancelled order and a distributor who buys through two subsidiaries. If the standard permissions model handles both cases, the package has saved you engineering work you would otherwise own.

On the custom side, AI can help a team draft an ERP connector, generate test fixtures or prototype a search interface. The team still has to check that permissions survive an account merger, detect a failed sync and maintain the integration when the ERP changes. Productivity assumptions deserve a trial. In a 2025 randomized study, experienced open-source developers took 19% longer on the studied tasks when allowed to use the AI tools available at the time. The result was specific to those developers, repositories and tools. Measure a representative change in your own system before putting a productivity gain into the budget. METR’s study and methodology

A three-year portal comparison

Suppose 300 distributors use the portal every month. Finance and operations agree that fewer support calls and less invoice handling would free up €84,000 of usable capacity each year. The following figures are illustrative assumptions, not vendor quotations. Both options cover the same workflows, service hours and AI usage. To make the arithmetic visible, the first comparison assumes three full years of benefit and excludes tax and discounting.

  • Buy. Setup and integration cost €36,000. At €12 per active distributor per month, three years of licences cost €129,600. Administration, support and AI usage add €12,000 a year. Total cost is €201,600.
  • Build. Initial delivery costs €108,000. Hosting, model usage, maintenance and support cost €27,000 a year. Total cost is €189,000.

Against €252,000 of benefit, the package returns €50,400 above cost, or 25% ROI. Custom development returns €63,000, or about 33%. Count freed capacity as a benefit only if the organisation can redeploy it or avoid an expense. Otherwise, revise both estimates.

Find the assumption that changes the answer

At 150 active distributors, the package costs €136,800 over three years. Under these assumptions, its cost crosses the custom option at about 271 active distributors. Timing matters just as much. If custom delivery starts generating benefits two months later than the package, it gives up €14,000 within the same evaluation window. That alone outweighs its €12,600 cost advantage at 300 users.

Give both bidders the same acceptance case and ask them to price 150, 300 and 600 active users. Request a date for the first usable release and an explicit price for the next ERP change. Those answers turn an impressive AI demo into a decision your finance team can revisit as adoption grows.

No items found.
September 18, 2026

Buy or Build? How AI Changes the Software ROI Equation

A vendor demonstrates an invoice-search assistant built into its portal. A development team shows you a similar feature it produced in an afternoon. Both demos work. Your investment decision depends on a harder question: how much will it cost to give every distributor the right invoice, reliably, for the next three years?

Price the work that survives the demo

Packaged software can put a working feature in users’ hands early. Find out which licence includes it, whether external users need paid seats, and how usage above the allowance is charged. Test it with a cancelled order and a distributor who buys through two subsidiaries. If the standard permissions model handles both cases, the package has saved you engineering work you would otherwise own.

On the custom side, AI can help a team draft an ERP connector, generate test fixtures or prototype a search interface. The team still has to check that permissions survive an account merger, detect a failed sync and maintain the integration when the ERP changes. Productivity assumptions deserve a trial. In a 2025 randomized study, experienced open-source developers took 19% longer on the studied tasks when allowed to use the AI tools available at the time. The result was specific to those developers, repositories and tools. Measure a representative change in your own system before putting a productivity gain into the budget. METR’s study and methodology

A three-year portal comparison

Suppose 300 distributors use the portal every month. Finance and operations agree that fewer support calls and less invoice handling would free up €84,000 of usable capacity each year. The following figures are illustrative assumptions, not vendor quotations. Both options cover the same workflows, service hours and AI usage. To make the arithmetic visible, the first comparison assumes three full years of benefit and excludes tax and discounting.

  • Buy. Setup and integration cost €36,000. At €12 per active distributor per month, three years of licences cost €129,600. Administration, support and AI usage add €12,000 a year. Total cost is €201,600.
  • Build. Initial delivery costs €108,000. Hosting, model usage, maintenance and support cost €27,000 a year. Total cost is €189,000.

Against €252,000 of benefit, the package returns €50,400 above cost, or 25% ROI. Custom development returns €63,000, or about 33%. Count freed capacity as a benefit only if the organisation can redeploy it or avoid an expense. Otherwise, revise both estimates.

Find the assumption that changes the answer

At 150 active distributors, the package costs €136,800 over three years. Under these assumptions, its cost crosses the custom option at about 271 active distributors. Timing matters just as much. If custom delivery starts generating benefits two months later than the package, it gives up €14,000 within the same evaluation window. That alone outweighs its €12,600 cost advantage at 300 users.

Give both bidders the same acceptance case and ask them to price 150, 300 and 600 active users. Request a date for the first usable release and an explicit price for the next ERP change. Those answers turn an impressive AI demo into a decision your finance team can revisit as adoption grows.

No items found.

Related Services

No items found.

Tags

No items found.

get in touch.

Tell us about your goals!
Contact Sales

Your next chapter
starts with a conversation.

Let’s make it happen
The Digitalist Team
September 18, 2026

Buy or Build? How AI Changes the Software ROI Equation

A vendor demonstrates an invoice-search assistant built into its portal. A development team shows you a similar feature it produced in an afternoon. Both demos work. Your investment decision depends on a harder question: how much will it cost to give every distributor the right invoice, reliably, for the next three years?

Price the work that survives the demo

Packaged software can put a working feature in users’ hands early. Find out which licence includes it, whether external users need paid seats, and how usage above the allowance is charged. Test it with a cancelled order and a distributor who buys through two subsidiaries. If the standard permissions model handles both cases, the package has saved you engineering work you would otherwise own.

On the custom side, AI can help a team draft an ERP connector, generate test fixtures or prototype a search interface. The team still has to check that permissions survive an account merger, detect a failed sync and maintain the integration when the ERP changes. Productivity assumptions deserve a trial. In a 2025 randomized study, experienced open-source developers took 19% longer on the studied tasks when allowed to use the AI tools available at the time. The result was specific to those developers, repositories and tools. Measure a representative change in your own system before putting a productivity gain into the budget. METR’s study and methodology

A three-year portal comparison

Suppose 300 distributors use the portal every month. Finance and operations agree that fewer support calls and less invoice handling would free up €84,000 of usable capacity each year. The following figures are illustrative assumptions, not vendor quotations. Both options cover the same workflows, service hours and AI usage. To make the arithmetic visible, the first comparison assumes three full years of benefit and excludes tax and discounting.

  • Buy. Setup and integration cost €36,000. At €12 per active distributor per month, three years of licences cost €129,600. Administration, support and AI usage add €12,000 a year. Total cost is €201,600.
  • Build. Initial delivery costs €108,000. Hosting, model usage, maintenance and support cost €27,000 a year. Total cost is €189,000.

Against €252,000 of benefit, the package returns €50,400 above cost, or 25% ROI. Custom development returns €63,000, or about 33%. Count freed capacity as a benefit only if the organisation can redeploy it or avoid an expense. Otherwise, revise both estimates.

Find the assumption that changes the answer

At 150 active distributors, the package costs €136,800 over three years. Under these assumptions, its cost crosses the custom option at about 271 active distributors. Timing matters just as much. If custom delivery starts generating benefits two months later than the package, it gives up €14,000 within the same evaluation window. That alone outweighs its €12,600 cost advantage at 300 users.

Give both bidders the same acceptance case and ask them to price 150, 300 and 600 active users. Request a date for the first usable release and an explicit price for the next ERP change. Those answers turn an impressive AI demo into a decision your finance team can revisit as adoption grows.

No items found.
September 18, 2026

Buy or Build? How AI Changes the Software ROI Equation

A vendor demonstrates an invoice-search assistant built into its portal. A development team shows you a similar feature it produced in an afternoon. Both demos work. Your investment decision depends on a harder question: how much will it cost to give every distributor the right invoice, reliably, for the next three years?

Price the work that survives the demo

Packaged software can put a working feature in users’ hands early. Find out which licence includes it, whether external users need paid seats, and how usage above the allowance is charged. Test it with a cancelled order and a distributor who buys through two subsidiaries. If the standard permissions model handles both cases, the package has saved you engineering work you would otherwise own.

On the custom side, AI can help a team draft an ERP connector, generate test fixtures or prototype a search interface. The team still has to check that permissions survive an account merger, detect a failed sync and maintain the integration when the ERP changes. Productivity assumptions deserve a trial. In a 2025 randomized study, experienced open-source developers took 19% longer on the studied tasks when allowed to use the AI tools available at the time. The result was specific to those developers, repositories and tools. Measure a representative change in your own system before putting a productivity gain into the budget. METR’s study and methodology

A three-year portal comparison

Suppose 300 distributors use the portal every month. Finance and operations agree that fewer support calls and less invoice handling would free up €84,000 of usable capacity each year. The following figures are illustrative assumptions, not vendor quotations. Both options cover the same workflows, service hours and AI usage. To make the arithmetic visible, the first comparison assumes three full years of benefit and excludes tax and discounting.

  • Buy. Setup and integration cost €36,000. At €12 per active distributor per month, three years of licences cost €129,600. Administration, support and AI usage add €12,000 a year. Total cost is €201,600.
  • Build. Initial delivery costs €108,000. Hosting, model usage, maintenance and support cost €27,000 a year. Total cost is €189,000.

Against €252,000 of benefit, the package returns €50,400 above cost, or 25% ROI. Custom development returns €63,000, or about 33%. Count freed capacity as a benefit only if the organisation can redeploy it or avoid an expense. Otherwise, revise both estimates.

Find the assumption that changes the answer

At 150 active distributors, the package costs €136,800 over three years. Under these assumptions, its cost crosses the custom option at about 271 active distributors. Timing matters just as much. If custom delivery starts generating benefits two months later than the package, it gives up €14,000 within the same evaluation window. That alone outweighs its €12,600 cost advantage at 300 users.

Give both bidders the same acceptance case and ask them to price 150, 300 and 600 active users. Request a date for the first usable release and an explicit price for the next ERP change. Those answers turn an impressive AI demo into a decision your finance team can revisit as adoption grows.

No items found.

Related Services

No items found.

Tags

No items found.

Become a Digitalk partner

International go-to-market with some clicks
Create your account

Become a Digitalk partner

Explore the partner programme